Criminalisation and licensing is wrong, don’t support Porter’s Bill!
Porter’s Bill has progressed through the WA Parliament and now there is new urgency for action to be taken. NAUWU has begun another letter writing campaign to address this Bill lobbying all WA MP’s to research and think about the issues sex workers will face if they vote for Porter’s Bill.
Attorney General Christian Porter’s proposed Bill will:
- ban sex work in residential areas
- license and register sex workers and auxiliary staff
- impose restrictions on sex industry advertising
- increase criminal penalties for non-compliance
- expand related police powers
_
NAUWU’s lobbying work so far on this issue:
NAUWU has previously written on the proposed law reform on the following page which details submissions made by NAUWU, Scarlet Alliance and other peers in the industry.
http://nothing-about-us-without-us.com/the-sex-industry-in-western-australia-proposed-law-reform-and-submissions-from-sex-worker-activists-in-nsw/
_
The Bill itself and WA Parliament explanatory notes are here:
WA Prostitution Bill 2011_Porter’s Bill still needing final vote to pass
WA Prostitution Bill 2011 Explanatory Notes
_
NAUWU’s latest letter
You can find our letter below which provides Western Australian MP’s information on why the Bill should not pass and the consequences if they vote yes to Porter’s Bill.
Criminalisation and licensing is wrong. Don’t support Porter’s Bill_ WA letter writing campaign to WA MPs
_
Who did we send the letter to?
The list of MP’s we sent it to and their contact details can be found on the link below. We encourage everyone to do an email out to any and all MP’s to help inform and lobby them on this issue.
Porter’s Bill letter writing campaign email list for lobbying_current 2011
_
Adele Carles response to our letter
NAUWU has received a response to the letter writing from Adele Carles, MLA, Member for Freemantle which you can read below. Although it is not what NAUWU and WA sex workers need to hear; and her position is NOT what Western Australian sex workers need and what she proposes would in fact be one of the worst possible outcomes, we are mindful of the fact she is the only one out of 27 MP’s contacted who bothered to respond.
From: Carles, Adele <Adele.Carles@mp.wa.gov.au>
Date: Fri, Dec 16, 2011 at 4:41 PM
Subject: WA Prostitution Bill
To: Nothing Without <nothingaboutuswithoutus@gmail.com>
Dear Nothing About Us Without Us,
PROSTITUTION BILL
Thank you for your email. I appreciate receiving your views on this legislation that is set to be debated when Parliament resumes in February 2012. As you may be aware, prostitution is currently illegal in Western Australia. This new legislation seeks to change this, by creating legal areas from which this industry can operate. I have reviewed the legislation and I do have many concerns in relation to it.
As an Independent female MP, I am particularly concerned about prostitution, as it impacts on many of the most vulnerable and marginalised women in our State. My primary concern is for the women who are exploited in this industry – I want to ensure that their rights and needs come first. You may be interested to know that the numbers in our Parliament are particularly close for this bill. Ironically, it looks like Janet Woollard and myself, 2 Independent female MPs, may well determine the fate of this legislation. This is a responsibility I take very seriously.
I am interested in the Swedish model, after reading about its success in combating prostitution in Scandinavia. Next month I am travelling to Scandinavia to meet with policy makers in relation to the Swedish model. I will also be meeting with various stakeholders to understand the workings of the Swedish model and to get a sense of its impact on society, 10 years after its introduction.
Please be assured that I will consider equally, all perspectives, from all stakeholders in determining the best long term solution in response to the Government’s proposed Prostitution Bill. I will contact you when I have decided how to respond to this controversial legislation. Again thank you for sharing your views with me. I encourage you to continue informing me of you views and perspectives on civil society matters in Western Australia.
Yours sincerely,
Adele Carles, MLA
Member for Fremantle
Shop 1, Queensgate Centre
William Street, Fremantle WA 6160
Tel: 9336 7000 Fax: 9430 4564
NAUWU’s reply to Adele Carles
NAUWU is opposed to the Swedish Model and believes anyone who supports such a model needs to be informed about the great harms it imposes on the sex industry. NAUWU wrote the letter you will find below to Ms Carles to help her understand what potential dangers she would be exposing sex workers to if she continued to support the Swedish Model.
In this letter you will find links to research that has been conducted in countries where the Swedish Model has been introduced and research and papers from Australia looking at decriminalisation, legalisation, regulation and the different effects each model of this has had on different States within Australia.
NAUWU response to Adele Carles_December 2011
_
We have had no further response from Adele Carles
NAUWU will continue to contact the MP’s detailed on the list above asking for a response to out letter. When we receive more information on the Bill or any responses to our letter, we’ll let you know!
_
Note: NAUWU makes every effort to ensure the quality of the information available on this website. Before relying on the information on this site, however, users should carefully evaluate its accuracy, currency, completeness and relevance for their purposes, and should obtain any appropriate professional advice relevant to their particular circumstances. NAUWU cannot guarantee and assumes no legal liability or responsibility for the accuracy, currency or completeness of the information.
Disclaimer: Images used on this site have been used with the permission of all parties pictured. If you happen to find an image of yourself and do not wish for it to appear on http://www.nothing-about-us-without-us.com please let the webperson of this site know by contacting nothingaboutuswithoutus@gmail.com .
Contributions on http://www.nothing-about-us-without-us.com have been made by NSW Sex Workers and other concerned parties of NSW Sex Industry; site design and maintenance by nothingaboutuswithoutus@gmail.com ; Copyright Nothing About Us Without Us 2009 – 2020




Follow NAUWU on Twitter