Trafficking in Australia;
“Vigilante approach is wrong,
Prevention is key.”
say Sex Workers
*taken from Scarlet Alliance Media Release 11th October 2011
_
Sensationalist media
Over the last week Australian media has been flooded by sensationalised reports regarding the issues of trafficking and regulation in the Australian sex industry, but more specifically in Melbourne and NSW. In the 5 day period from the 8th October up until today the 13th October 2011 these media articles have included:
http://nothing-about-us-without-us.com/why-did-abraham-papo-die-the-sydney-morning-herald-08-10-11/
http://nothing-about-us-without-us.com/terrible-price-of-a-trade-in-misery-the-sydney-morning-herald-08-10-11/
http://nothing-about-us-without-us.com/human-trafficking-prompts-raids-on-brothels-the-sydney-morning-herald-08-10-11/
http://nothing-about-us-without-us.com/legal-brothels-linked-to-international-sex-trafficking-rings-the-sydney-morning-herald-10-10-11/
http://nothing-about-us-without-us.com/licensing-law-to-tighten-screws-on-brothel-chiefs-the-sydey-morning-herald-11-10-11/
http://nothing-about-us-without-us.com/never-a-game-the-sydney-morning-herald-11-10-11/
http://nothing-about-us-without-us.com/brothel-firebombing-linked-to-turf-war-the-sydney-morning-herald-11-10-11/
and of course the Four Corners program which can be found at this link:
http://www.abc.net.au/4corners/stories/2011/10/06/3333668.htm
The above articles were cross published in The Age, The Sydney Morning Herald, The Brisbane Times, WAToday and on the ABC website.
The articles and Four Corners program included the sensationalist terms:
“hundreds of legal brothels…..thousands of women ….. brutal industry….lives in danger… sex slavery….. sexual servitude”
_
FLESH TRADE: Four Corners teaser and cross promotion of media
Along with the articles listed above, each appeared with what the newspapers named “FLESH TRADE: Four Corners teaser”. This “FLESH TRADE teaser” was a video that included hidden camera footage of workers in brothels being filmed without their knowledge or consent; a “journalist” driving around in his car stopping out the front of licensed brothels in VIC and brothels in NSW who have DA consent to operate, pointing out that they were brothels and would more than likely have illegal workers in them working in sexual servitude; commentary on how the next Four Corners program would blow the lid off the Flesh Trade in Australia and expose sexual servitude, sex slavery, trafficking, contract workers and that they were run by gangs, murderers and other criminals in huge numbers and how this behaviour is the norm in the Australian sex industry.
Examples of these Flesh Trade Teasers can be found here:
http://media.theage.com.au/news/national-news/flesh-trade–four-corners-teaser-2676045.html
http://www.smh.com.au/national/the-flesh-trade
http://www.brisbanetimes.com.au/national/legal-brothels-linked-to-international-sex-trafficking-rings-20111009-1lfxs.html
The Age newspaper and The Sydney Morning Herald were in partnership with Four Corners and running a cross promotion where all three media were able to promote each other and benefit by sensationalising the same issue. By doing this not only is this promotion and awareness achieved, but the issue can be seen by the public to gain more credibility and the ability to sensationalise an issue and make it larger than life is multiplied three fold.
_
NOTE: In the 2 months leading up to this media coverage, Scarlet Alliance did over the phone interviews with the journalists involved with producing theses articles for Fairfax media (SMH, The Australian) and the Australian Broadcasting Corporation (for the Four Corners program). However, Four Corners chose not to interview Scarlet Alliance, it’s members, NAUWU, or anyone from the asian sex worker organisations for this particular edition of the show. The Farifax media journalists chose not to use any of Scarlet Alliance’s material in their written coverage.
_
The response
The sex working community was appalled. People responded by writing blogs, commenting on the articles as they were published by each media group, discussing the issues on forums, Twitter campaigns, directly contacting the media groups who published and aired the material, press releases were put out by sex worker organisations, website campaigns were launched and complaints made to the Press Council. Please see below for examples.
Media releases:
Scarlet Alliance media release in response_ Trafficking in Australia; “Vigilante approach is wrong, prevention is key” say sex workers_11th October 2011
SWOP media release_Brothel Licencing and Illegal Safe Sex_October 2011
The Australian Sex Party Media Release_Sex Slavery Caused by Failure of Moral Policy
Sex worker comments:
“4 corners… use to be a childhood memory of ‘good journalism’.. now a stain in my consciousness… sad but true…”
R********
“…Now is the time to come together as a community. 4 Corners should have outraged us with the appalling one sided representation not given people permission to judge. 4 Corners should bring us together as a powerful lobbying community. You should be outraged!”
Dora Explorha
“…the show could have been on Today Tonight instead of Four Corner’s”
QueerRTchoke
“…did anyone pick up on the fact they actually took hidden cameras into the line ups, rooms etc and video’d woman without their knowledge or permission?! And they preach how evil it is these very woman they were videoing are being taken advantage of, used and abused for other people’s gain and given no choice. Disgusting hypocrits.”
IGP
“One of the main points about all these articles an even the program itself is that they are high on speculation and very low on fact. The unsafe sex in Sydney brothels article is a prime example where their only evidence is that say so of one brothel owner that other brothels in her area (not her own) may practise un safe sex.
I would add the results of the LASH project – we have the evidence that voluntary STI checks undertaken in consultation with individual’s medical practitioner as to how often, if at all, an individual sex worker ought to submit to a sexual health screen is best practice and works. According to the LASH project, NSW has best outcomes in terms of sexual health and access by representative bodies such as SWOP. Until the LASH Report to NSW Government is in the public domain, one of the papers produced from the study ‘Improving the health of sex workers in NSW: maintaining success’ says it all. Abstract from published paper Vol. 21(3-4)2010 NSW Public Health Bulletin Donovan et al
“NSW has a diverse sex industry that is limited in its size by modest demand. There is no evidence that decriminalisation in 1995 increased the frequency of commercial sex in NSW. Though the largest sector, female brothels, is now mainly staffed by Asian women, condom use for vaginal and anal sex exceeds 99% and sexually transmissible infection rates are at a historic low. These gains are attributable to the long-term support of the NSW Department of Health in collaboration with the community-based Sex Workers Outreach Project and sexual health services, facilitated by the removal of criminal sanctions without the expense and access barriers of licensing systems”
Julie
Websites:
http://www.sexparty.org.au/index.php/news/media-releases/1229-sex-workers-say-anti-trafficking-crusaders-are-not-our-friends
http://www.thepunch.com.au/articles/slavery-in-australia-goes-beyond-the-sex-trade/
http://www.sexparty.org.au/index.php/news/media-releases/1218-no-one-is-listening-to-us-sex-workers
NGO Delegation to the UNAIDS PCB_Trafficking truth and lies_it’s time to decriminalise
Sex worker blogs:
http://becauseimawhore.wordpress.com/2011/11/08/stop-the-traffic-the-car-crash-you-cant-look-away-from/
http://ryrysparkleby.tumblr.com/post/11267692856/sex-trafficking-rant
http://ashaaaa.wordpress.com/2011/10/10/migrant-exploitation-and-labour-trafficking-is-not-exclusive-to-the-sex-industry/
Meetings attended and representation given:
Sex Party NSW_Migrant Sex Workers Myth and Misconception
http://www.sexparty.org.au/index.php/videos/1245-sex-workers-andrew-patterson-
http://www.sexparty.org.au/index.php/videos/1244-sex-slavery-elena-jeffreys-fiona-patten
Radio:
ABC Radio Australia_Australian sex worker group opposes moves to police industry
Government Organisations:
PLA In Touch Newsletter_Issue 64_December 2011
_
Where to now and what can you do?
NAUWU is taking further action to hold Fairfax Media and The Australian Broadcasting Corporation accountable for their inaccurate and biased media coverage. Since this page was first published, there has also been media from different sources including Channel 10 and print media that NAUWU is concerned about. We will continue to lobby, advocate, and educate on the issues of trafficking and sex work and the need for Australian media to represent the issues in a fair and accurate manner. We will continue to work with sex workers including sex worker peer based organisations to address these issues.
If you’d like to help, we’d love it if you could…
- Get onto internet forums and give your feedback to the media articles
- Share the above media release
- Contact the media outlets whose reporting is most biased and sensationalist
- Tell us your opinion!- place a comment after this article
- talk about the issues on Twitter and Tweet this page
- send us an email to nothingaboutuswithoutus@gmail.com
- join NAUWU by sending us an email
- write a blog discussing the issues
- talk with other sex workers
We will keep you informed of any updates and with further information!
Note: NAUWU makes every effort to ensure the quality of the information available on this website. Before relying on the information on this site, however, users should carefully evaluate its accuracy, currency, completeness and relevance for their purposes, and should obtain any appropriate professional advice relevant to their particular circumstances. NAUWU cannot guarantee and assumes no legal liability or responsibility for the accuracy, currency or completeness of the information.
Disclaimer: Images used on this site have been used with the permission of all parties pictured. If you happen to find an image of yourself and do not wish for it to appear on http://www.nothing-about-us-without-us.com please let the webperson of this site know by contacting nothingaboutuswithoutus@gmail.com .
Contributions on http://www.nothing-about-us-without-us.com have been made by NSW Sex Workers and other concerned parties of NSW Sex Industry; site design and maintenance by nothingaboutuswithoutus@gmail.com ; Copyright Nothing About Us Without Us 2009 – 2020